Evangelicalism is dead, long live evangelicalism.
For what it’s worth, these thoughts are some thoughts that I’ve been processing. These opinions are my own.
I feel a bit torn. In an earlier post, I described myself as an “evangelical.” I’m not sure how helpful a label that is anymore. Actually, I’m not sure I would call myself a “Christian.” Bear with me a moment; it’s not as provocative as it sounds.
Words matter, but do they? I’m old enough to remember (way back a few weeks ago) when domestic terrorists breached our nation’s capitol building seeking to change the result of an election (and bring harm to those deemed as “enemies”). Not only was the act itself jarring, but the number of Christian flags and other symbols of Christianity being used to justify the act was deeply disturbing (and, for me, absolutely infuriating.) Many Christian leaders rightly rebuked the actions taken that day, while others correctly commented, “That’s not Christianity!” The problem is – it is. At least by way of identification and labels.
The way “evangelical” has been used broadly in the media has only further muddied the term. Surveys allow people to “self-identify” as such, how Christians have used it hasn’t helped much either. (Tracing the usage of the word, you’ll find the “evangelicalism” we see today falls more under the category of “fundamentalism” … thoughts for another time.) The label “Christian” has similar problems.
If you asked someone (especially those outside the Christian bubble), “What is a Christian?” you might get a variety of answers (same with “evangelical”). The answers will likely be justified and, likely, very wrong. The response would be defined by what they perceive Christians to be, based on what they see those who identify as Christians do. According to Jesus, this is how it’s supposed to work (see the first part of John 13:35.)
American Christianity appears to be stereotyped as those who are slow to listen, quick to speak, and quick to get angry. Willing to take from others when they perceive a loss or danger; grasping worldly (political) power to maintain status, privilege, and comfort. Other descriptions are just as opposite Jesus (or “anti”-Christ.) I’d love to say this describes “other” people, except I’ve been prone to head in those directions and have seen these thought patterns in myself.
“Evangelical” comes from the word “gospel” or “good news.” It describes those motivated by the proclamation and demonstration (note: intentionally redundant since I believe “proclamation” includes word AND deed) of the good news of salvation brought by Jesus Christ; embodying the kingdom of God. “Christian” is one who belongs to and reflects Jesus, the One who came to seek and save those far from Him.
I find it intriguing early followers of Jesus didn’t call themselves “Christians” (“Followers of the Way” didn’t catch on.) It was in Antioch where they were first called Christians (Acts 11:26), likely as a term of mockery, by those who didn’t believe yet. A label given, not one self-identified.
This is why I say I’m not sure if I would call myself a Christian. If after hearing me talk about who transformed my life and who I seek to pattern my life after. As I express the ways I am broken and how Jesus offers me restoration. As you hear me talk about and demonstrate this incredible love God has for you and point to Jesus - His life, death, burial, and resurrection - as the source of it. If my love and care for my wife, my kids, and those around me looks like what I’ve shared (and, with humility, I repent when it doesn’t). If you notice joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control that reminds you of Jesus. If that’s why you want to call me a Christian? Great!
While the “evangelicalism” that bore the fruit of the Capitol attack is dead (I mean this as a comparison to the life Christ offers, unfortunately this type of “evangelicalism” is still very much prevalent), the solution is for Christians to call it out for what it is and embody Christ to the world around us. That’s good news brought to life.